Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Listings

Area Average

Median over the active for-sale listings

Median Listing Price

$842,202

Median Days on EXIT Realty®

53

Median Square Feet

1,600

Median Price per Sq./ft.

$482

Compare

Compare Shelter Island, NY to another area

Market Composition

• 479 Residential (For Sale)
• 109 Multi-Family
• 55 Commercial
• 52 Land
• 50 For Lease
• 43 Commercial Lease
• 6 Business

50 active rentals

Nearby Schools

• Shelter Island School

  School · 0.8 mi away

• Greenport Elementary School

  Elementary · 3.6 mi away

• Sag Harbor Elementary School

  Elementary · 4.9 mi away

• Sag Harbor Union Free School District Page

  School · 5.1 mi away

• Pierson High School

  Secondary · 5.1 mi away

• Harbor Waldorf School

  School · 5.4 mi away

• Our Sons and Daughters

  School · 5.4 mi away

• Southold Elementary School

  Elementary · 5.6 mi away

• Southold Junior Senior High School

  Secondary · 5.6 mi away

• Oysterponds Elementary School

  Elementary · 5.8 mi away

• Head Start

  School · 5.9 mi away

• Ross Lower School

  School · 7.6 mi away

• Ross School

  Elementary · 7.7 mi away

• The Green School

  School · 7.9 mi away

• Cutchogue East Elementary School

  Elementary · 8.0 mi away

• Hayground School

  School · 8.4 mi away

• Bridgehampton School

  School · 8.7 mi away

• CDCH Charter School

  School · 8.8 mi away

• Mattituck-Cutchogue School Dist

  School · 9.0 mi away

• East Hampton High School

  Secondary · 9.1 mi away