Skip to content
Photo 1 of 32
Photo 1 of 32 — 236 Windsor Avenue, Brightwaters, NY 11718
View all 32 photos

236 Windsor Avenue, Brightwaters, NY 11718

Suffolk County

Key Facts

5Beds
4Baths
3,130Sq Ft
1962Year Built
0.51Lot (acres)
1Garage

Description

Welcome to a home where timeless elegance meets exceptional craftsmanship in the heart of the Village of Brightwaters. Perfectly positioned on one of the area’s most sought-after streets, this beautifully appointed residence offers luxury finishes, flexible living spaces, and an extraordinary backyard retreat designed for both everyday living and unforgettable entertaining. At the heart of the home is a custom chef’s kitchen featuring granite countertops, under-cabinet and in-cabinet lighting, a double convection oven with a warming drawer, and an induction cooktop—a space as functional as it is beautiful. The stunning cathedral-ceiling primary suite is a true retreat, complete with two custom walk-in closets, new skylights that fill the room with natural light, and a spa-inspired primary bath featuring a luxurious soaking tub. Every upstairs bedroom and bathroom is enhanced with custom-designed closets, providing exceptional organization and storage. The versatile lower level offers brand-new flooring, a new full bathroom, and an expansive office suite with two private offices and a waiting room, making it ideal for a home-based business, professional workspace, guest quarters, multigenerational living, or a nanny suite. Step outside into your own private resort. The professionally designed backyard showcases a heated lap pool with cascading waterfalls, an outdoor fireplace, and a built-in outdoor kitchen with granite countertops, creating the perfect setting for entertaining or relaxing. An upper Trex deck overlooks the spectacular grounds, while a 12-zone in-ground sprinkler system keeps the lush landscaping looking its best. A circular driveway adds both elegance and convenience to the home’s impressive curb appeal. Located in the charming Village of Brightwaters, residents enjoy tree-lined streets, a private village park, tennis courts, a community dock, summer concerts, holiday celebrations, and a true small-town atmosphere—all while being just minutes from vibrant downtown Bay Shore, waterfront restaurants, Fire Island ferries, beaches, parks, and the LIRR for an easy commute to Manhattan. This is more than a home—it’s a lifestyle defined by luxury, comfort, and one of Long Island’s most desirable communities

Property Information

Property Type

Residential

Sub-Type

Single Family Residence

Style

Hi Ranch

Year Built

1962

Living Area

3,130 sq ft

Lot Size

0.51 acres

Garage Spaces

1

Days on Market

2

MLS® Listing#

1024524

Property Features

Interior:
Eat-in Kitchen
Appliances:
Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Cooling:
Central Air
Heating:
Natural Gas
Pool:
Private
Parking:
Attached, Driveway
Construction:
Brick, Vinyl Siding
Utilities:
Electricity Connected, Water Connected
Sewer:
Public Sewer
Water Source:
Public

Schools

Elementary:
Gardiner Manor School
Middle:
Bay Shore Middle School
High:
Bay Shore Senior High School

HOA & Tax

Annual Tax:
$23,594
Assessed Value:
$69,000
Parcel #:
0501-008-00-02-00-058-000

Affordability Calculator

$259,800

Estimated monthly payment

$6,914/mo

Principal $1,039,200 · Est. interest $1,449,776 over 30 yrs

Neighborhood Market Statistics

How this home compares to active listings in Brightwaters, NY

$966,667
Median Listing Price
8
Median Days on Market
2,280
Median Sq Ft
$442
Median Price / Sq Ft
5
Active Listings
  • This home’s price is 34% above the area median.
  • Its price per sq ft is 6% below the area median.

Market statistics compiled from active EXIT Realty® and MLS listings in Brightwaters, NY.

Location

  • 236 Windsor Avenue, Brightwaters, NY 11718

Walk Score

Walk
Bike

Somewhat Walkable

Walk Score details ↗

Nearby Schools

  • St Patrick School

    School · 0.4 mi away

  • South Country Elementary School

    Elementary · 0.9 mi away

  • New Beginnings Preschool

    School · 1.0 mi away

  • Gardiner Manor Elementary School

    Elementary · 1.0 mi away

  • Fifth Avenue School

    Elementary · 1.1 mi away

  • Bay Shore Senior High School

    Secondary · 1.2 mi away

  • Brook Avenue Elementary School

    Elementary · 1.5 mi away

  • Bay Shore Christian School

    School · 1.8 mi away

  • Heritage Christian Academy

    School · 1.8 mi away

  • Bay Shore Middle School

    Secondary · 1.8 mi away

  • Oquenock Elementary School

    Elementary · 2.0 mi away

  • Mary G. Clarkson Elementary School

    Elementary · 2.0 mi away

  • Captree Elementary School

    Elementary · 2.1 mi away

  • Bayview Elementary School

    Elementary · 2.1 mi away

  • Islip Middle School

    Secondary · 2.2 mi away

  • St. John the Baptist Diocesan High School

    Secondary · 2.2 mi away

  • Islip School District

    School · 2.2 mi away

  • Beach Street Middle School

    Secondary · 2.3 mi away

  • Islip High School

    Secondary · 2.3 mi away

  • West Islip Public Schools

    School · 2.3 mi away

Commute Calculator

Travel mode

Nearby Homes

Similar Homes Nearby

Moving Cost Estimate

EXIT Agents in Brightwaters

Listing Courtesy: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC - 6316651500

Presented by: Tammy J. Ramsay

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright ©2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved
Fair Housing Notice

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of one or more Multiple Listing Services (MLS). Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. Copyright © EXIT Realty® and respective MLS providers.

Data provided by LIBOR. MLS® Listing#1024524. © 2026EXIT Realty®. All rights reserved.